
So I just finished another three hour session putting Tycho to bed. I’d say that these are rare and that a more typical time is 45minutes to an hour, but sometimes when I try to shorten it things spiral out of control.
The doctor says that he should be able to fall asleep on his own without us lying down with him, but we’ve simply never trained him to do that, so he gets quite anxious trying to sleep alone. He can be really really tired, but when I try to leave, he just starts getting upset that I’m not doing my job and taking care of him.
Here’s where the crucial decision in parenting style comes in. I think the popular child-rearing strategy these days is to be a little tough, and use the crib or other techniques to just draw an absolute line, and then let the baby adapt. I have no doubt that after a few days or weeks of something pretty strict that Tycho would adapt.
But here’s the rub. Up until now, I think Tycho has been a remarkable open and well adjusted little boy, mostly because I think he knows he has so much love and people are always watching out for him. My fear is that part of Tycho’s adaptation to a solitary bed-time would be to pull away a little, and maybe to view the world as a slightly more cold and lonely place.
So tonight I experimented with a strategy to gradually make him more comfortable being on his own, which almost worked, though it does take a lot of patience.
Keep in mind that there are many outcomes I’m looking for in this process:
- I want him to feel safe and cared for going to bed.
- I want him to know that he can depend on us when he needs us.
- I want him to be able to relax and get to sleep in 10-15 minutes, assuming we put him to bed at a reasonable time.
So before I tell you the strategy, let me tell you something that I did that I feel did not work, and why. About two weeks ago I was having a similar problem, so I decided if I couldn’t get Tycho to sleep, at least I could train him to stay in bed. So I put him down, and sat with him until he was almost sleeping, then got out of the room. He started crying almost as soon as I had left, got out of bed and was at the door of the bedroom in under a minute. So I picked him up, put him in bed and left. I thought that I could continue this process a la SuperNanny and just wear him down. Eventually, I decided to short circuit the procedure a little bit an intercept him just as he was getting out of bed. After about ten attempts he did indeed learn that there was no point getting out of bed, but the whole experience left him feeling very stressed out, probably betrayed and not at all wanting to sleep.
The key observation here was the short circuiting, and the observation that the outcome we want is for him to feel safe and relaxed, rather than wanting him to simply have the behavior of staying in his bed.
So tonight, I experimented with this strategy, which worked not as well as I had hoped, but perhaps with practice will.
I started by lying down with him, which is exactly what he wants, and waited until he got comfortable, maybe waiting for him to take 5-10 deep breaths. When I felt sure he was comfortable, I would sit up as if I was leaving. After a few seconds he would notice that I was sitting up and he would sit up too. At this point, I know that he’s feeling worried and a little stressed out, even though his behavior isn’t breaking any “rules”. So I would lie down, and then he would lie down. After that I could wait a little while for him to get comfortable, and then sit up again. After a few repetitions, I was able to increase the duration of my sitting up to a minute or so without causing him to stir, at which point I started moving to a chair by the bed, and then the rocking chair a little further away, and finally the door.
One important point is that although I was moving away from him the whole time, I wasn’t moving away monotonically. I fact it seemed that he was most relaxed when I would sort of fade in and out of his sphere of awareness every few seconds. I think this helps because he’ll learn quickly that my pulling away is very temporary and nothing to be alarmed about.
Unfortunately tonight, things fell apart when I got to the door, and I was out of patience to start over completely. I think this method takes a lot of sensitivity, because things can spiral out of control if you pull away too fast. I probably should have responded to the first sign of discomfort on his part, instead of overt behaviors like sitting up. I’m hopeful that if I try this tomorrow results will be better, and that after a few days Tycho will be comfortable with a fairly rapid departure.
But the basic point is to let Tycho know that even though I’m busy and have things to do I’ll be as close to him as he needs me to be as long as he asks.